Aoife O’Donovan at Rockwood Music Hall Stage 2

Send to Kindle

Aoife O’Donovan headlined a set at Rockwood Music Hall Stage 2 last night. Just as with the set before, I have been hearing about Aoife from my friend Kevin for a very long time now. Unlike the previous set, Kevin is not the only person to tell me that I had to see Aoife. Just yesterday morning I received an email from my friend Jamie in MN telling me that if he were in NYC, he’d be going to see last night’s show.

Before telling you why, I will say that I too am now firmly on the Aoife O’Donovan bandwagon. If you consider me a friend (as I do Kevin and Jamie), then you can mark today as the day I started bugging you to get to an Aoife show!

I had to say that first, because undoubtedly, I will never do justice to how I felt watching the set, so I’m asking you to trust me and experience it for yourself, rather than judge my words to decide whether you think you’ll like it. Onward.

Aoife O’Donovan has a gorgeous voice. At least in last night’s set, it fell squarely in the camp of singers like Alison Krauss and Ruth Moody (two of my favorites). In other words, there’s an ethereal quality to their voices, and it tends to sound a bit soprano, even when it’s not.


She is a superb songwriter, lyrics and melodies. In fact, one of the songs she wrote, Lay My Burden Down, was covered by Alison Krauss and Union Station on their latest CD, Paper Airplane. Alison’s version is so faithful to Aoife’s, it’s another compliment to Aoife’s skill that her arrangement didn’t need to be embellished.

She is in a group called Crooked Still (which is how I first heard about her) that is currently on hiatus (giving her time to perform her own music and tour with others).

In addition to performing her own music, she has performed with Goat Rodeo Sessions. That project features Yo-Yo Ma, Chris Thile, Edgar Meyer and Stuart Duncan. I saw them perform on The Tonight Show with Jay Leno, where Aoife and Chris Thile sang harmony throughout the number. Gorgeous!

Last night she opened the show finger-picking an electric guitar. She was great, and I was marginally surprised when she announced that it was the first time she’s played the electric guitar in public. After the second song, she switched to her trusty Martin acoustic, and continued to finger-pick a storm. She returned to the electric late in the set. She’s a very good guitar player.


All that’s left is to describe the music itself. It’s a little hard to do in general, but harder without having mentioned the amazing band yet. Still, I’m going to do my best, followed by noting each band member.

The overwhelming feel I had was bluegrass and country meet jam band. When Aoife sings, it’s a dream-like bluegrass/country sound (depending on the song), often having very similar qualities to some of Alison Krauss’ best work. When she stops singing and the band takes over (they’re playing incredible stuff even while she’s singing), it turns into a quintessential jam band feel, with everyone showing off their virtuosity, but never straying from the basic structure of the song (like I feel a lot of classic jazz does, but what do I know).


To summarize, when Aoife is singing, the lyrics are fantastic, her voice is fantastic and the band behind her is incredible. When she stops singing, the band (including her, still finger-picking) kick it into a gear where you don’t wonder when the singing will start up again, and you (specifically I) could get lost in the music forever. Then she starts singing again, and you welcome that part back with open arms.

It’s largely minor-key progressions that they are jamming to, giving it some of the dream-like qualities. It’s in the music in between the singing that makes Aoife’s music quite different from Alison Krauss’.

The band, left-to-right on stage:

Ryan Scott on electric guitar and vocals. Ryan was extraordinary on the electric guitar. He was a large component of what gave the music the jam band feel, as he’s able to progressively build guitar leads that get fuller and richer with every measure, climbing the scale and getting your heart pumping faster along the way. He sang a bit of harmony (nicely) as well.


Robin MacMillan on drums. Robin impressed me in the previous set, but he cranked it up a couple of notches here, with the freedom of the jam band feel. Seriously, he fit in perfectly with some very serious musicianship. He’s firmly on my list of drummers to keep seeing.


Jacob Silver on electric bass. Jacob (Jake) floored me the previous set, and did nothing but add to that in this set. He’s a mind-bogglingly good bass player, with a sensibility (and the speed) to deliver constant melodies rather than straightforward bass lines (not that there’s anything wrong with straightforward). Not to beat a dead horse, but when you’re jamming, having a bass player who is essentially harmonizing with a top lead guitarist, is a thing to behold.


Charlie Rose on pedal steel guitar. I love pedal steel guitar, and I rarely get to see it. Thank you Charlie for coming down from Boston and giving me more than a taste. In addition to taking some wonderful leads, Charlie was the glue that gave the band a true bluegrass feel. During a number of the jam sessions, he complemented or traded leads with Ryan on the guitar.


Aoife invited up the headliner from the previous set, along with her guitar player, to sing harmony on one number with her.

Kristin Andreassen and Chris Eldridge joined for some 3-part harmony goodness. Lovely in every respect.


Whew. I was taken by every single number. It’s rare that I don’t want a set to end (even if I love it). I didn’t want this one to end (even though we badly needed to leave when it was over).

On the way out, I bought Aoife’s 5-song EP, called The Peachstone EP. I absolutely love it, but it’s not identical sounding to the live show, even though all five songs were performed last night, and a few of them have exactly the same musicians on the tracks.

One difference is the vocals. On track 1, Glowing Heart, Aoife is singing stunning harmony with herself. On the other hand, there’s not very much of the jam band feel between verses. It’s gorgeous, just much more structured and moving quickly from verse to verse. The jam band feel would have made it more like a live album.

Not to be inconsistent, I’ll call out the fact that it’s quite unusual these days to charge $10 for a 5-song EP. I have no regrets that I purchased it, but since I’ve called out others for this kind of pricing, I think it’s fair to note it here as well.

Aoife announced that she’ll be at Joe’s Pub on April 29th (9:30pm show). We will be there too, so should you.

Here’s the set list:



8 responses to “Aoife O’Donovan at Rockwood Music Hall Stage 2”

  1. thingles Avatar

    Now I’m going to need to be jealous all the future times that you see Aoife in New York now that she is living there. 🙂 I’m glad you enjoyed the show. I think her voice is amazing and I was really bummed that she played in Minneapolis a little bit ago and I didn’t know about it until too late. Luckily someone I knew from Twitter was there and picked up the EP for me.

    I also adore pedal steel by the way. The pedal steel work on Uncle Tupelo and Son Volt albums is just amazing. At one point I wanted to buy one and put it in the living room so I could pick and slide on it, fully realizing that would likely be as far as my musical talent would take me on it.
    The Crooked Still albums are worth listening to as well. I first heard Crooked Still and Aoife at the Winnipeg Folk Festival. 🙂

  2. hadar Avatar

    You should still get the pedal steel. I’m sure you’ll surprise yourself first, then the rest of us, when you master it! If not, then one of the kids will! 🙂

  3. Phil Avatar

    I want Peachstone EP bad, but can’t buy it at one of Aoife’s live shows because don’t live in the US.
    I sent her messages on Twitter and she told me that for now Peachstone EP is only available at her live shows.

    Could anyone help me to have a copy of Peachstone? I pay $20 via Paypal.

  4. hadar Avatar

    I saw her tweet, and I’m hoping someone will be able to help you out. 🙂

  5. Phil Avatar

    Thank you.
    Are the other songs of Peachstone as good as the track “Glowing Heart”.Just curious.

  6. hadar Avatar

    I like the whole EP, so yes. That said, Glowing Heart is really good. I just returned from a long walk and just listened to it before I saw your comment.

  7. Drew R. Avatar
    Drew R.

    I can’t find so much as a track listing for the Peachstone EP anywhere. I know it has “Glowing Heart” and “Red & White & Blue & Gold” on it, but what are the other three songs? And are they the same versions as on Fossils or different/earlier versions?

    Any info anyone could provide would be greatly appreciated.

  8. hadar Avatar

    Here is the track listing:

    01 Glowing Heart
    02 Briar Rose
    03 Red And White And Blue And Gold
    04 I’m Alone
    05 Lay My Burden Down

    As for whether any of these are duplicates or different versions from earlier LP’s, unfortunately, I have no idea. Sorry!

    Hope this helps.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *